lace_agate: (breathe)
[personal profile] lace_agate
I started reading the books a couple of weeks ago because I wanted to read them before the movie came out. I raced through the first one and it just stuck in my head, so I went out and bought the second and devoured it in an afternoon. The third took me a bit longer because I was finding it a bit too grim, but I finished it the day I saw the movie and the ending made me cry in a good way.

First off, I really liked Katniss. I know some people found her difficult to relate to, but I found quite a lot to identify with - like Katniss, I'm socially awkward and bad at reading people, I also love to sing, and I can empathise with Katniss's desire to be her own person and with her mental health problems.
I also liked the books' narration style. I know that they're not brilliantly written, but for me that actually adds something to the story because they felt like they could have actually been written by Katniss. I like that Katniss is a somewhat unreliable narrator and I even like the limitation of the first-person narrative to some extent - I'm a politics student; I like trying to figure out for myself how exactly the regime change took place (but that's an essay for a different time).
I liked Peeta and I ship Katniss/Peeta pretty enthusiastically. I like that Peeta tries to be good and kind, and that he sometimes fucks up or doesn't understand how people will react to his kindness.
I didn't particularly like Gale as a person, but I liked him as a character - I could see how he came to be as angry and ruthless as he is.
I felt that the books did a good job of fucking with traditional and expected gender roles. Katniss's role in the story is a role more often filled by male characters than female ones: a humanised hero, a survivor, a bit ruthless, a bit morally ambiguous - compare her to many action heroines who are portrayed as sexualised cardboard cut-outs (I know this is a generalisation; of course there are exceptions!). Peeta and Finnick would likely have been female in many versions of the story - Peeta as a baker, an artist, a more nurturing character than Katniss, fills many feminine archetypes, while Finnick is a tough fighter who happens to be a survivor of multiple rapes and forced prostitution - how many female action heroes have rape as their backstory? How many male ones? I could go on, but you get the idea.
Now, about the film... I really liked it, but I felt that the arena in the film lacked the visceral horror it had in the books. I'm sure this was partly to avoid getting an R rating, but it made some of the violence feel a bit glossed over. The shaky camera was a bit distracting at times, but for the Reaping scene it was perfect. I liked the decision to show Seneca Crane and the gamemakers as a subplot; it filled some of the gaps left by the loss of Katniss's internal monologue and added a bit more horror to the story.
Now, about the Great Casting Kerfuffle: I don't mind that they cast a white woman as Katniss, but I'm pissed off that the casting call specified Caucasian - non-white actresses didn't even get a chance to try for the role. The whiteness of District 12 also bothered me a bit. As for the disgusting racists who complained about Rue, Thresh and Cinna being black in the film - STFU and learn reading comprehension! Rue and Thresh are black in the book, Cinna could be any ethnicity, and all three actors were perfect for their roles. I hope that the filmmakers cast more people of colour in the second film: how about Johanna? Finnick? Mags? Beetee and Wiress? Anyone?
tl;dr: books were fantastic, movie was good, read the books, see the movie, opinionate, flail or rant in comments.
Anonymous( )Anonymous This account has disabled anonymous posting.
OpenID( )OpenID You can comment on this post while signed in with an account from many other sites, once you have confirmed your email address. Sign in using OpenID.
Account name:
If you don't have an account you can create one now.
HTML doesn't work in the subject.


Notice: This account is set to log the IP addresses of everyone who comments.
Links will be displayed as unclickable URLs to help prevent spam.


lace_agate: (Default)

October 2016

9 101112131415

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 25th, 2017 02:33 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios